icon showing phone turned sideways

Because it is laid out in columns, this site doesn't display properly on a phone held vertically.

Please turn it sideways.

148
backnext page
Critiquing documents

Trust and graphic design

Can graphic design ever be too good? Can it tip over into insincerity?

No items found.

Can graphic design ever be too good? Can it tip over into insincerity?

Will Stahl-Timmins is the data graphics designer for the BMJ, a leading medical journal. In a talk1 he mentioned the issue of trust, almost as an aside. In his experience, well-finished graphics in a medical context can sometimes be mistaken for pharma marketing.

Here in the UK we don’t have pharmaceutical advertising to the public, but we have plenty of toothpaste ads in which improbably good-looking dentists in very cool labs tell us how we can get whiter teeth. It’s the same thing.

Graphic design dresses information in a costume that communicates personality. This affects how sincere we think it is, or how expert, how professional. Credibility is critical for health information right now.

1. Will Stahl-Timmins ‘A picture of health: Visualising medical information for doctors’, International Institute for Information Design, 22 October 2022.

How this helps
When you envisage your reader, remember that they will also be forming an image of you or your client. Overdesigning can backfire.
Things like this
Search